Glancing Upstream: Summer 2016 Retrospective and Review

Diving in for one last look at summer’s little treasures.


The Fall season may be well under way, but that doesn’t mean we can’t take some time to bid fond farewell to our Summer standouts. After spending two weeks out of town and then writing a whole lotta final thoughts on orange and 91 Days, my schedule’s a mess right now (I haven’t even finished all of the shows on my summer watchlist), so this post will be shorter and more informal than usual so I can get it out before the Fall season overtakes me completely. Thanks in advance for your understanding!

As all that may suggest, Summer’s been pretty hectic on my end thanks to a second move, family events, new writing projects, and the aforementioned two-week trip, so maybe it’s no surprise that I gravitated toward lighter comedies and escapism this season. That said, there are still a trio of shows on this list that’ll punch you right in your feels pouch. Good thing you’ve got those other soothing shows to help ease the sting, eh?

Oh–and I mentioned this during my Spring retrospective, but I’m retiring the numbered rankings in favor of a looser structure: I’m dividing them into general “tiers” and then just listing the shows within that tier alphabetically. So don’t take the order as any indication of quality–I liked everything on this list, and I’m glad they don’t have to compete with each other.

The Favorites Next Door

91 Days


Episode Count: 12
Studio: Shuka

In a Sentence: Seven years after the murder of his family, Angelo receives a letter with the names of their killers and begins to hatch a plot for revenge.
Content Warning: Violence (some graphic; against adults/teens and kids)

I covered this one for Anime Evo thinking it would be a straightforward gangster drama, then around the midway mark it dropped a bucket of cinematography, thematics, and subtle character development on my head and left me writing lengthier and more in-depth analyses each week. From start to finish it kept me on my toes with well-orchestrated tension and unexpected plot twists, all the while endearing me to its central cast of complicated, damaged young criminals. I was far too invested in this series, and that’s a very good thing.

I have a more detailed series review here, or you can check out my entire series of episodic mini-essays here.

Grade: A

Cute High Earth Defense Club LOVE! LOVE! (Binan Koukou Chikyuu Bouei-bu Love! Love!)


Season Episode Count: 12
Series Episode Count: 24
Studio: Comet

In a Sentence: A pink talking wombat grants five high schoolers the power to turn into the Battle Lovers, magical boys who fight for love and justice.
Content Warning: Partial nudity/fanservice (male); magical violence

I talked about this season in-depth on MyAnimeList, and my thoughts there held true through the finale. After taking a few episodes to find its footing, Season 2 became a non-stop giggle-fest of cheeky high school irreverence. Gleefully stupid and self-aware without being smug, Cute High parodies magical girls and high school dramas in equal turns, and always with just enough emotional honesty to keep it from devolving into pretension. I’m not sure anyone had more fun working on a series than the Cute High creative team did, and I’m not sure I had more fun watching a series than I did this one.

Grade: B+



Episode Count: 13
Studio: TMS Entertainment

In a Sentence: There are two surprises waiting for second-year student Naho on her first day of class: A transfer student named Kakeru, and a letter from her future self, offering her advice so she doesn’t make the same mistakes twice.
Content Warning: Deals with depression and suicide

orange’s central story and characters are well worth an “A” grade, but the poor production values and stretched-out pacing in its middle act drop it down a slight notch. That said, the writing is stellar, featuring a realistic group of teens and a sympathetic, nuanced depiction of grief, depression, and suicide. I loved the original manga, and while this adaptation isn’t quite as great as it could have been, it’s incredible when it counts, and left me an emotional puddle on more than one occasion.

I wrote a bunch about this one, too! You can click here for the full series review, or here for commentary on each episode.

Grade: B+

Thunderbolt Fantasy


Season Episode Count: 12
Studio: PILI Multimedia

In a Sentence: With the help of an enigmatic tactician and a gruff traveler, the idealistic Dan Fei must gather a team of unlikely allies to take back the holy weapon stolen from her shrine.
Content Warning: Violence (against puppets); some of the characters are sexist, but the gals themselves are pretty capable

Dangling plot lines and half-finished character arcs be damned–I loved this campy puppet fantasy. (And hey, for all I know, those issues will be resolved in the upcoming Season Two!) I could tell you about it, but you know what? Nick Creamer has already done it for me. So check out his recommendation/pitch over at Crunchyroll, and know that I’m standing somewhere just off-screen flashing a bunch of thumbs-ups and nodding enthusiastically to all of it.

Season Grade: B+

Solid Summer Series



Episode Count: 12
Studio: J.C. Staff

In a Sentence: This relaxing high school comedy follows anxious Futaba and chipper Hikari as they join their school’s scuba diving club, facing new challenges and building new friendships along the way.

I came so close to dropping this one, but Director Sato’s inherent charm eventually won me over, and I’m so glad it did. Amanchu is a warm, lightly comedic story about taking chances, overcoming anxiety, and finding the fun and beauty (thank you, gorgeous underwater art) in everyday life.

The series sometimes fumbles when it turns its attention to the supporting cast (although their teacher is a delight), especially when it relies on tired “girl uses boy as punching bag”-style slapstick. Still, it’s honest and moving when focusing on the shy, high-strung Futaba, her fears, and her building relationship with Pikari. A happy surprise, and just the soothing weekend show I needed.

Grade: B

Mob Psycho 100


Episode Count: 12
Studio: BONES

In a Sentence: Junior high student and powerful ESPer Mob does his best to deal with school clubs, telepathic rivals, family strife, and his part-time job as an exorcist’s assistant.
Content Warning: Violence; depictions of bullying

I dropped Mob Psycho after the third episode because I couldn’t deal with its unrelentingly anxious tone, but I gave it another try once my own life wasn’t quite so stressful, and I ended up finishing it just in time for this write-up. I’m still in a weird place with this one, because even though I didn’t exactly enjoy it, I think it’s one of the best shows of the season.

While what’ll likely stand out most is its dynamic animation and unique, evocative art direction, this isn’t a matter of “all style no substance”–Mob Psycho is also a smart, moving coming-of-age story about social outcasts, wanting to change, the misconceptions of power, and the importance of kindness. Add to this an endearing, awkward protagonist and his equally endearing con artist of a mentor, along with ONE’s dry, offbeat humor, and you’ve got the recipe for a fascinating little series, bombastic and thoughtful in equal measures. Personal discomfort aside, I’m very glad I came back to it.

Grade: You know what? Pass. My relationship with this one is so odd that I don’t feel I can give it a proper grade.

Sweetness and Lightning (Amaama to Inazuma)


Episode Count: 12
Studio: TMS Entertainment

In a Sentence: Struggling to raise his young daughter on his own, recently widowed Inazuka Kohei decides to improve his culinary skills–and finds an unlikely cooking class partner along the way.

Sweetness and Lightning is adorable and charming. It’s also one of the better shows I’ve seen in terms of writing little kids, depicting kindness and concern alongside mood swings and tantrums (oh hey, I think I just figured out why it’s called Sweetness and Lightning! Fancy that!). Every so often it touches on more emotional issues of grief and loneliness, but mostly it’s a cute cooking show about a cute kid and her cute dad building a found family.

It’s very nice, which is both a strength and a weakness, because while S&L regularly delighted me (and got me to crave new foods each week), it’s not a show I ever missed or thought about when I wasn’t watching it. Still, it left me with regular warm fuzzies, and that’s nothing to sneeze at. If you like cooking shows or are in the mood for something light and sweet, this little series might be right up your alley.

Grade: B

Shorts & The Unfinished Batch


Of course I finished Bananya, which continued to be a show about bananas who are also cats, and there is literally nothing else you need to know about it. It was weird and fun and exactly what it needed to be. I mean, just look at those li’l cuties.

There are also a few shows I started and haven’t finished for various reasons, although I also haven’t officially dropped them either. Figured it was worth mentioning them, so:

  • Battery: I came into this one late, got sucked into the first 4-5 episodes, but then got yanked out again thanks to repetitive dramatics and some disorienting pacing as they tried to cram a novel into 11 episodes. I’m two from the end so once my schedule evens out I’ll probably wrap it up, but I’m not all that excited about it.
  • Cheer Boys!! Despite some at-times excellent character drama, my enthusiasm for Cheer Boys keeps fading, largely because, even though it can be quite good, it doesn’t feel like it’s living up to its potential both in terms of story and animation. I’m 2 or 3 from the end so, like Battery, odds are high I’ll finish it. Just not sure when.
  • Kuromukuro: Waiting on Netflix to release the second half. It’s a fun mecha show, so I’m looking forward to seeing where the story goes next.
  • New Game!! I gave this one a second try a few days ago because I’d heard good buzz and was in need of something silly and cute. It has the usual cute-girl show problems (tonally dissonant fanservice, mostly), but it’s fairly sparse, and the all-female video game team makes for a great setting for workplace shenanigans. Not sure I’ll ever finish it, but I thank it for the night of stress relief even so.

How about you, lovely readers? What was your favorite show of the season? Sound off in the comments below!

6 thoughts on “Glancing Upstream: Summer 2016 Retrospective and Review

  1. I wrote up my ANN Best of the Season without finishing several of the ones you have here that I’ve been watching, notably 91 Days and Orange. I’m trying to work on that now before getting too invested in the new season. And of course, I’m loving 91 Days. It’s right up my alley — the soundtrack is so good, and I love both period dramas and gangster films — and I wonder if I’ll regret my picks once I finish it…

    Liked by 1 person

  2. Rae says:

    I have mixed feeling wrt to Mob Psycho 100 which is odd since I like the manga but somehow the anime didn’t really live up to expectations? I do agree it has a anxious/suffocating feeling b/t scenes .


  3. 91 Days was my favourite show of the season, closely followed by Orange. Sweetness and Lightning was pretty cute too, and I’m sure glad I’m not the only one who enjoyed the hell out of the campy awesomeness that was Thunderbolt Fantasy.

    I also finished Cheer Boys – shame about the budget but great to see a down-to-earth sports anime/an anime about cheerleading that didn’t pander to either gender or go anywhere near the fanservice route. Oh, and Morse Mononokean was okay too.

    Liked by 1 person

  4. Hmm … the top “A rank series” of the summer season for me would have been: Amanchu, Mob Psycho 100, New Game and the Planetarian OVAs.

    Mob Psycho was a surprise for me – I thought Bones really hit it out of the park. The other three I expected to be very well done, and for me they were. ^^

    Liked by 1 person

  5. Dominic Cuthbert says:

    Just keeping up with a few shows for a whole season seems in itself a minor miracle, so it’s perfectly understandable that life should come along and play havoc with your schedule. I know it has mine.

    The tier system seems like a decent idea, and certainly a less stressful way of organising shows than with outright numbers. We ditched ratings on our reviews about a year ago, haha.

    Amanchu! was one of the biggest surprises – an earnest and moving exploration of anxiety and overcoming it. Sure, the glacial slice-of-life pacing could be testing at times, but I found each episode a mini tear jerker in its own right. I just couldn’t binge the show. One episode every few days was more than enough. The same could be said of Sweetness and Lightening, a show I devoured as greedily as they did the food in the show :P

    I actually enjoyed New Game!! whilst still groaning and rolling my eyes and all the irksome aspects. I like to have one of those sorts of shows on the go every season, as there’s usually something surprising about each one in amongst the (as you say) fanservice, queer-baiting and usual cute-girl problems.

    My favourites, almost like everyone else, were the obvious ones – Mob Psycho 100 and 91 Days etc etc.

    Liked by 1 person

Leave a Reply

Please log in using one of these methods to post your comment: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s